[pulse] Check the validity of the addresses captured by lambda only for captures by reference

Summary: To look for captured variable address escape we should only check the validity of the addresses captured by reference. Checking the validity of the address captured by value can cause nullptr dereference false positives.

Reviewed By: jvillard

Differential Revision: D25219347

fbshipit-source-id: faf6f2b00

infer/src/pulse/PulseOperations.ml

@@ -28,24 +28,36 @@ module Closures = struct
 
   let fake_capture_field_prefix = "__capture_"
 
-  let mk_fake_field ~id =
+  let string_of_capture_mode = function
+    | Pvar.ByReference ->
+        "by_ref_"
+    | Pvar.ByValue ->
+        "by_value_"
+
+
+  let fake_captured_by_ref_field_prefix =
+    Printf.sprintf "%s%s" fake_capture_field_prefix (string_of_capture_mode Pvar.ByReference)
+
+
+  let mk_fake_field ~id mode =
     Fieldname.make
       (Typ.CStruct (QualifiedCppName.of_list ["std"; "function"]))
-      (Printf.sprintf "%s%d" fake_capture_field_prefix id)
+      (Printf.sprintf "%s%s%d" fake_capture_field_prefix (string_of_capture_mode mode) id)
 
 
-  let is_captured_fake_access (access : _ HilExp.Access.t) =
+  let is_captured_by_ref_fake_access (access : _ HilExp.Access.t) =
     match access with
     | FieldAccess fieldname
-      when String.is_prefix ~prefix:fake_capture_field_prefix (Fieldname.to_string fieldname) ->
+      when String.is_prefix ~prefix:fake_captured_by_ref_field_prefix
+             (Fieldname.to_string fieldname) ->
         true
     | _ ->
         false
 
 
   let mk_capture_edges captured =
-    List.foldi captured ~init:Memory.Edges.empty ~f:(fun id edges captured_addr_trace ->
-        Memory.Edges.add (HilExp.Access.FieldAccess (mk_fake_field ~id)) captured_addr_trace edges )
+    List.foldi captured ~init:Memory.Edges.empty ~f:(fun id edges (mode, addr, trace) ->
+        Memory.Edges.add (HilExp.Access.FieldAccess (mk_fake_field ~id mode)) (addr, trace) edges )
 
 
   let check_captured_addresses action lambda_addr (astate : t) =
@@ -57,7 +69,7 @@ module Closures = struct
           IContainer.iter_result ~fold:Attributes.fold attributes ~f:(function
             | Attribute.Closure _ ->
                 IContainer.iter_result ~fold:Memory.Edges.fold edges ~f:(fun (access, addr_trace) ->
-                    if is_captured_fake_access access then
+                    if is_captured_by_ref_fake_access access then
                       let+ _ = check_addr_access action addr_trace astate in
                       ()
                     else Ok () )
@@ -71,7 +83,7 @@ module Closures = struct
     let captured_addresses =
       List.filter_map captured ~f:(fun (captured_as, (address_captured, trace_captured), mode) ->
           let new_trace = ValueHistory.Capture {captured_as; mode; location} :: trace_captured in
-          Some (address_captured, new_trace) )
+          Some (mode, address_captured, new_trace) )
     in
     let closure_addr_hist = (AbstractValue.mk_fresh (), [ValueHistory.Assignment location]) in
     let fake_capture_edges = mk_capture_edges captured_addresses in
@@ -487,9 +499,12 @@ let apply_callee ~caller_proc_desc callee_pname call_loc callee_exec_state ~ret
 let get_captured_actuals location ~captured_vars ~actual_closure astate =
   let* astate, this_value_addr = eval_access location actual_closure Dereference astate in
   let+ _, astate, captured_vars_with_actuals =
-    List.fold_result captured_vars ~init:(0, astate, []) ~f:(fun (id, astate, captured) var ->
+    List.fold_result captured_vars ~init:(0, astate, [])
+      ~f:(fun (id, astate, captured) (var, mode) ->
         let+ astate, captured_actual =
-          eval_access location this_value_addr (FieldAccess (Closures.mk_fake_field ~id)) astate
+          eval_access location this_value_addr
+            (FieldAccess (Closures.mk_fake_field ~id mode))
+            astate
         in
         (id + 1, astate, (var, captured_actual) :: captured) )
   in
@@ -506,9 +521,9 @@ let call ~caller_proc_desc err_log ~(callee_data : (Procdesc.t * PulseSummary.t)
       in
       let captured_vars =
         Procdesc.get_captured callee_proc_desc
-        |> List.map ~f:(fun (mangled, _, _) ->
+        |> List.map ~f:(fun (mangled, _, mode) ->
                let pvar = Pvar.mk mangled callee_pname in
-               Var.of_pvar pvar )
+               (Var.of_pvar pvar, mode) )
       in
       let+ astate, captured_vars_with_actuals =
         match actuals with

infer/tests/codetoanalyze/cpp/pulse/closures.cpp

@@ -405,3 +405,12 @@ S* update_inside_lambda_as_argument(S* s) {
 int update_inside_lambda_as_argument_ok_FP(S* param_s) {
   return update_inside_lambda_as_argument(param_s)->f;
 }
+
+std::function<void()> get_lambda(bool b) {
+  return [b]() -> void { return; };
+}
+
+void capture_false_by_value_ok() {
+  const auto& f = get_lambda(false);
+  f();
+}