Summary:
Currently the equality classes are computed from the representatives
solution substitution when needed. This diff instead maintains them as
part of the representation of the context. By itself this does not
make a huge difference, but it is necessary to make other operations
incremental.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25883715
fbshipit-source-id: 1b444a0dc
Summary:
The solver for single equations no longer needs access to the internal
representation of the context.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25883722
fbshipit-source-id: 4ccd97674
Summary:
When `no_fresh` is true, then no fresh variables will be generated
while solving. So it is not necessary to provide a set with respect to
which variables must be generated fresh.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25883724
fbshipit-source-id: fd886067f
Summary:
Currently when solving an equation requires solving one or more other
equations, they are handled recursively. This diff reworks the solver
to instead queue pending equations in a list rather than eagerly
solving them eagerly. The pending list will be needed when changing
the Context.t representation since some equations will need to be
delayed until representation invariants are re-established.
Additionally, the solution is accumulated as an association list
rather than being eagerly incorporated into the context
representation. This enables the uses in equality solving and
quantifier elimination to use different representations.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25883727
fbshipit-source-id: 2f6b5efa3
Summary:
When used by the first-order solver, solve_extract may generate fresh
variables to express the solution substitutions, but when used by
quantifier elimination via solve_for_vars, fresh variables should not
be generated. This diff makes the difference between these use cases
simpler and clearer by replacing the obscure filter predicate argument
that is passed eventually to compose1 with a boolean indicating
whether fresh variables may be generated.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756562
fbshipit-source-id: 53a35b71c
Summary:
Context.solve_for_vars returns a solution substitution consisting of
oriented equalities that are implied by the given context. It is
logically valid to express these equations using terms that are
normalized with respect to the solution substitution itself. This diff
normalizes uninterpreted terms with the solution substitution when
extending it. This preserves the logical strength of the solutions,
and strengthens other purely syntactic operations on the substitution,
such as Context.Subst.is_valid_eq.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756582
fbshipit-source-id: cd997c46b
Summary:
- Fix clamping of percentage change of memory quantities
- Improve sorting of coverage changes relative to unchanged error
results
- Filter out results for invalid LLVM code
- Fix printing multiple status values
- Fix passing args to sledge, different subcommands need different
args
- Fix cleaning commands
- Add an unknown error status to the report if sledge exits without
producing a status in the report
- Internalize globals for tests, as otherwise C++ tests are unreadable
due to the runtime system models
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756567
fbshipit-source-id: 3b4c003f4
Summary:
The ~20% hit in compilation time is dominated by the time saved
running the tests. This also makes the memory allocation numbers more
robust to inconsequential changes. Note that `make check` is still
fast.
Note that normally dune passes `-g` to ocamlopt itself, but not if the
build profile includes an `ocamlopt_flags` entry. So add it explicitly
to ensure that compilation includes debug symbols.
(Also remove `-error-style short` that was missed in 9c4f263.)
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756570
fbshipit-source-id: 94d18bac2
Summary:
When a stem has an occurrence of an existential, say x, and x is
substituted out by different witnesses, say a and b, in two disjuncts,
then the connection to other occurrences of a and b are lost.
This diff fixes this problem by propagating the solved variables that
survive normalization down to subformulas, and not removing those
variables from subformulas.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756583
fbshipit-source-id: dabda743f
Summary:
Trade a bit more code for lowering complexity from linear to
logarithmic.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756569
fbshipit-source-id: 83ad575fe
Summary:
Composing two substitutions does not need to require that their
domains are disjoint.
Leave disjointness check for composing a single mapping just to check
expected usage.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756557
fbshipit-source-id: 04e92b864
Summary:
The overall operation of the quantifier elimination algorithm in
Sh.simplify is to first descend through the disjunctive structure of a
symbolic heap formula, process the leaves, and then proceed back up
the formula. At each point on the way back up, the first-order solver
is used to compute a solution substitution representing witnesses of
existential variables. This substitution is then used to normalize the
entire subformula at that point. Note that this results in
substituting and normalizing each subformula a number of times
proportional to its depth in the disjunctive structure.
This diff removes this redundancy and substitutes through each
subformula once. This is done by changing from an overall bottom-up to
top-down algorithm, and involves composing solution substitutions
rather than substituting multiple times. This change also heavily
relies on the strengthened Context.apply_and_elim operation, where the
bottom-up many-substitutions approach relies on the internal details
of repeated substitutions.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756549
fbshipit-source-id: ca7cd814a
Summary:
The current implementation of quantifier elimination in Sh.simplify is
tightly coupled with the details of what the Context operations
support. In particular, successfully eliminating variables with
Context.elim effectively relies on being given a context that has been
transformed by Context.apply_subst. These operations are sound
independently, but achieving the desired result is delicate.
To simplify this situation, this diff refactors the tightly coupled
usage into a Context.apply_and_elim operation that hides the details
of the interaction inside the Context module. This enables an accurate
specification of apply_and_elim to be given much more simply than can
be done for the separate operations. This also simplifies the
implementation of Sh.simplify.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756577
fbshipit-source-id: b344b3da6
Summary:
The implementation of quantifier elimination in Sh.simplify currently
relies on a subtle implementation detail of Context.apply_subst to
remove some identity mappings. Now that Context.elim has been
strengthened and generalized, it can be used to to give a much clearer
implementation, that is also more robust to representation changes in
Context.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756554
fbshipit-source-id: 6be0de2f3
Summary:
The current implementation of Context.elim crudely removes oriented
equations from terms involving the given variables. This is easy to
use in a way that violates the representation invariants of Context,
as well as destroys completeness. This diff resolves this by making
Context.elim remove the desired variables by rearranging the existing
equality classes, in particular promoting a new representative term
when the existing representative is to be removed. Also, since this
basic approach is incomplete for interpreted terms, they are detected
and not removed. As a result, the interface changes to return the set
of variables that have been removed.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756573
fbshipit-source-id: 0eead9281
Summary:
Context.fold_uses_of should enumerate the transitive subterms of a
term rather than only the immediate subterms.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756553
fbshipit-source-id: a3911d9f5
Summary:
Previously Sh had a representation invariant which ensured that
existentials of a subformula did not shadow universals of its
superformulas. The current implementation of Sh.freshen_nested_xs
mistakenly still assumes this invariant, but it no longer holds. This
diff fixes freshen_nested_xs to freshen nested existentials with
respect to not only ancestor universals in addition to existentials.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756551
fbshipit-source-id: 54c48b067
Summary:
Sh.simplify propagates first-order constraints over the formula's
propositional structure, and can reveal inconsistency. It is therefore
sometimes beneficial to check consistency after simplifying rather
than before.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756585
fbshipit-source-id: 2a205c965
Summary:
Simplifying a symbolic heap can reveal inconsistencies, either of
individual disjuncts or (therefore) of toplevel formulas. This is due
to the first-order contexts being propagated from a formula to its
descendents, and for the intersection of the contexts of disjunctions
being propagated to their parent. The later stages of eliminating
redundant quantifiers, etc. do not reveal further
inconsistencies. Therefore this diff moves the inconsistency detection
earlier, to just after the contexts are strengthened. This is clearer,
and also a minor optimization.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756564
fbshipit-source-id: d3acf875b
Summary:
Sh operations usually detect inconsistency where needed. But some
operations such as Context.inter must treat the unsat case
specially. This diff increases robustness by not relying on Sh to
detect inconsistency in order to get the correct context or pure
constraints, or to use the fast-paths through Context or Formula
operations.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756550
fbshipit-source-id: 091439ff6
Summary:
Sh.is_false checks if the pure constraints are inconsistent with the
first-order consequences of the spatial constraints. This involves
some, though not very expensive, logical reasoning. But is it not
checking only testing for the representation of Sh.false_, which one
might expect from its name. This renaming also makes room for the
operation that does test for the representation of Sh.false_.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756580
fbshipit-source-id: 30510f45a
Summary:
Context.apply_subst erroneously resets everything in the
representation of a context except the solution substitution when
applying a substitution.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25756548
fbshipit-source-id: 949a34ced
Summary:
This is a simple CFG transformation that compresses jumps to jumps
into jumps to the final destination. LLVM's simplifycfg pass seemingly
should have eliminated these, but does not.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25196728
fbshipit-source-id: 3288dbd8d
Summary:
Currently the symbolic execution options, obtained from the command
line flags and preanalysis, are passed to the Control entry points as
a record, and then passed around within Control as needed. This diff
simplifies the code in Control by replacing the record mechanism with
an additional functor parameter containing the options. The main
benefit is that the bound option no longer needs to be part of the
analysis state.
This change does make the code in Sledge_cli slightly more
complicated, as it now performs a functor application using a
first-class module computed from the command line flags.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25196735
fbshipit-source-id: 80e5d5d62
Summary:
Revise the control-flow exploration scheduling algorithm to fix
several issues. The main difference is to change the priority queue to
keep the control edges on the frontier of exploration in sync with the
states that are waiting to be propagated. This fixes several sorts of
issue where the decision of which control and state joins to perform
was unexpected / wrong. Part of keeping the frontier edges and waiting
states in sync is that the waiting states are associated not only with
a destination block, but the stack of that block. This fixes several
issues.
Combined, these changes lead to the algorithm only attempting joins
for which the pointwise max join on depth maps is correct (with the
caveat of no mathematical proof yet).
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25196733
fbshipit-source-id: db007fe1f
Summary:
The first-order solver sometimes needs to generate fresh variables to
express the solution of equations. It needs to ensure that these
generated variables do not clash. Before this diff, there was a
confusion where new variables were fresh with respect to only the
current set of "universal" variables. This is wrong, and this diff
adds the full set of variables instead.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25196732
fbshipit-source-id: afc56834a
Summary:
It can happen that the actual return variable, which is the name of
the variable in the caller's scope that receives the returned value,
clashes with the formals of the callee. The scope of the return
formula was wrong in this case, as the actual return was outscoped via
existential quantification with the rest of the formals after the
return values was passed.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25196727
fbshipit-source-id: 94cf25418
Summary:
A context with valid but extraneous equations was being kept. The
extra equations are valid, but might violate vocabulary invariants.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25196734
fbshipit-source-id: a8001a075
Summary:
Currently there is a symbolic execution option to ignore exceptional
control flow. This hack does not fit well, and it is unclear how much
backend functionality should take it into consideration. This diff
removes this option and replaces it with an option during model
compilation. This has the advantage of clarifying and simplifying the
backend, with the disadvantage of no longer supporting switching
between exceptions and no-exceptions modes at analysis time. Since the
possibility of ignoring exceptional control flow is due to it not being
ready yet, this is a good trade to make.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146148
fbshipit-source-id: 1f1299ee1
Summary:
Use the equality class information in the symbolic state to resolve
callees of indirect calls.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146160
fbshipit-source-id: a1c39bbe1
Summary:
The callee function of a Call can often be resolved
statically. Currently this is resolution is only done dynamically
during symbolic execution by checking if the callee expression is a
function name and looking up the function in the program. This is
wasted and redundant work. Also, the static resolution code is
duplicated in all the domains.
This diff resolves this by resolving known callees statically at
translation time. This involves:
- add an ICall terminator that is the same as Call is currently
- change Call to use a func callee instead of Exp.t
- make callee field mutable since recursive calls can create cycles
- change the Llair.Term.call constructor to return a thunk to perform
the backpatching once the callee has been translated
- modify the Frontend
+ to determine whether to emit Call or ICall depending on whether
the callee in LLVM is already a Function
+ to record the LLVM function -- backpatch thunk pairs encountered during translation
+ record the mapping of LLVM to LLAIR functions during translation
+ to enumerate the calls to backpatch after all functions have been
translated, and find the LLAIR function corresponding to each LLVM
function and backpatch the call to use it as the callee
+ to handle direct calls to undefined functions, when backpatching
translate such function declarations into undefined functions
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146152
fbshipit-source-id: 47d2ca1ff
Summary:
Current code partially tries to handle Invoke, but incorrectly, and
these names are only needed for Call. So this diff revises this to be
slightly simpler and less confusing.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146157
fbshipit-source-id: ead4f6f31
Summary: Rework the intrinsic name detection to detect e.g. llvm.memset.*
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146150
fbshipit-source-id: 85ebcfb7a
Summary:
Rename the existing exec_intrinsic that works for calls to intrinsic
functions to exec_intrinsic_func to make room for an exec_intrinsic
that works on intrinsic instructions.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146166
fbshipit-source-id: 80ae3aac9
Summary:
The translation of instruction intrinsics that are `Invoke`d is almost
the same as those that are `Call`ed. The same Llair instruction is
produced, but it is wired into the CFG differently. This diff uses the
translation of instruction intrinsics used for `Call`s for `Invoke`s
as well.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146159
fbshipit-source-id: 85a93d915
Summary:
The code that computes the number of actuals is largely duplicated
between the Call and Invoke cases. But some issues have been fixed in
each that ought to be applied to the other. This factors out and
unifies this computation.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146149
fbshipit-source-id: 78552327a
Summary:
Move the translation of Calls to intrinsics that map to instructions
into a separat function.
No functional change.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146169
fbshipit-source-id: 79c640344
Summary:
Currently intrinsics are treated as functions, with Call instructions
to possibly-undefined functions with known names. This diff adds an
Intrinsic instruction form to express these more directly and:
- avoid the overhead of intrinsics needing to end blocks
- avoid the overhead of the function call machiery
- avoid the complexity of doing the string name lookup to find their
specs, repeatedly
This diff only adds the backend support, the added Intrinsic
instructions are not yet generated by the frontend.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146155
fbshipit-source-id: f24024183
Summary:
Previously, when LLAIR was in SSA form, blocks took parameters just
like functions, and it was sometimes necessary to partially apply a
block to some of the parameters. For example, blocks to which function
calls return would need to accept the return value as an argument, and
sometimes immediately jump to another block passing the rest of the
arguments as well. These "trampoline" blocks were partial applications
of the eventual block to all but the final, return value,
argument.
This partial application mechanism meant that function parameters and
arguments were represented as a stack, with the first argument at the
bottom, that is, in reverse order.
Now that LLAIR is free of SSA, this confusion is no longer needed, and
this diff changes the representation of function formal parameters and
actual arguments to be in the natural order. This also brings Call
instructions in line with Intrinsic instructions, which will make
changing the handling of intrinsics from Calls to Intrinsic less
error-prone.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146163
fbshipit-source-id: d3ed07a45
Summary:
Overwritten variables in move instructions are not impossible. Since
Domain_itv does not handle them, the check should be a `todo` rather
than an `assert false`.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146168
fbshipit-source-id: 13d8587c7
Summary:
It was possible for the scope of a local to be incorrectly restored
when entering it for the first time in a caller after is was shadowed
by a callee. This could happen because scope management in the
analysis relies on renaming variables to adjust the vocabulary of
symbolic states. This was usually done, but optimizations of renaming
with a substitution whose domain is disjoint from the vocabulary of a
formula inadvertantly violated this vocabulary-adjustment
assumption. (Yes, this is too easy to get wrong.)
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D25146162
fbshipit-source-id: 30f2d657f
Summary:
These are not simply handled by `@deriving` since:
- These types are recursive and so some fields need to be ignored
- Some are uniquely identified by one of their fields
- Some fields are mutable, but set only during construction, and need
to be considered by compare, equal, hash, but ppx_hash refuses.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D24989064
fbshipit-source-id: 7f8d699e5
Summary:
The use of realpath on paths obtained from debug info and the current
working directory is application-usage-specific behavior that does not
belong in the backend library. This diff moves these uses to the
frontend and cli, respectively. Also, the use of realpath in the
frontend is memoized along the same lines as the other frontend
translation functions.
This was also the last use of `core` in the `sledge` library, so the
dependency is moved to `sledge_cli` and `sledge_report`.
Reviewed By: ngorogiannis
Differential Revision: D24989070
fbshipit-source-id: c21b275f5
Summary:
Currently __llair_choice is left undefined, and so executed as skip.
This has the correct behavior, but makes it hard to distinguish from
calls to unintentionally-undefined procedures.
Reviewed By: ngorogiannis
Differential Revision: D24989068
fbshipit-source-id: f62981857
Summary:
Use B/K/M/G/... units for memory quantities, round percentages to 2
decimal places, and robustly detect deltas of close to zero.
Reviewed By: ngorogiannis
Differential Revision: D24989063
fbshipit-source-id: 35f0bccfb
Summary:
Instructions that have multiple specs sometimes have inconsistent
footprints for one or more of their specifications. In such cases, the
handling of the existential and universal vocabularies was sometimes
incorrect before this diff. In particular, the ghosts of a spec need
not appear in the pure approximation of the footprint, which the
previous code incorrectly assumed. Also, the unit of disjunction is
`false` with an empty vocabulary, not the precondition's vocabulary as
the previous code incorrectly used.
Reviewed By: ngorogiannis
Differential Revision: D24989067
fbshipit-source-id: eca3bff55
Summary:
Change `-llair-output` to `-output`, for binary form, and
`-llair-txt-output` to `-llair-output`, for textual form. Also
correspondingly change `.llair` to `.bllair`, for binary, and
`.llair.txt` to `.llair` for text.
This improves command line argument completion, and makes `.llair` the
extension of the files most commonly interacted with.
Reviewed By: ngorogiannis
Differential Revision: D24951506
fbshipit-source-id: ad4c73ca2
Summary:
The `seq` name of this field refers to the expected sort of it's
value, where the others refer to the role they play. So rename
seq (for sequence) to cnt (for contents).
Reviewed By: ngorogiannis
Differential Revision: D24951507
fbshipit-source-id: fd6640517
Summary: It is too easy to mix up multiple arguments of the same type.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D24934116
fbshipit-source-id: 6e595b26e
Summary:
Global constants have reliable types, and their sizes can be used
instead of storing the size of the initializer separately.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D24934114
fbshipit-source-id: 2426ab5be
Summary:
In practice this has not been observed to matter so far, since
treating `Splat N` as interpreted or uninterpreted does not matter
when `N` is a literal constant, and code seen so far only uses `Splat`
for zero initializers or memset with literal constant bytes.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D24934118
fbshipit-source-id: 213e9724e
Summary:
0 and Splat 0 need to be treated the same since code relies on knowing
that 0 consists of all-0 bytes, and extracting a subsequence of a
Splat 0 yields 0. For example, initializing a struct to all-zeros and
then reading a member of pointer type out of it needs to produce the
null pointer. Therefore 0 and Splat 0 are redundant representations,
and all uses of Splat need to be updated to also handle 0.
This unfortunately leads to some near code duplication that seems to
be necessary. The issue is that 0 and Splat 0 are, from the backend's
perspective, constants in two distinct theories. Since 0 is chosen
over Splat 0 as the representation, the sequence theory solver needs
to treat 0 as if it was Splat 0, which duplicates some code handling
the general Splat cases.
Reviewed By: jvillard
Differential Revision: D24920758
fbshipit-source-id: 7c02be62b
Josh Berdine